I suspect there is some confusion about SP3. If you have kept your Computer up-todate, 
via Windows Update, you already have everything you need from SP3.  

The Value in, and problem with SP3, as it stands, is that it encompasses ALL updates, 
Security and others, since SP2 was issued. This is true for Updates that are needed 
and not needed by individual Systems. (not sure if SP2 is included)

The problems encountered, I suspect, are caused by Operator expectations that SP3 
is needed, and will enhance performance, inspite of the fact that their System already 
has what is needed via Windows pdate.

The Value of SP3 is in having all the updates on-hand, should you need to reinstall 
WinXP+updates. Slipstreaming Updates into the Winxp Install media makes reloading 
windows much simpler, as long as only appropriate components are installed. One inappropriately 
installed component of SP3 could trash a new install. At 500+mb, Sp3 provides lots 
of room for errors/problems.

The problem is that this leaves it up to the SP3 Installer Package to determine which 
updates are needed by the current Configuration. (a function previously provided 
by the Windows Update Scan, on Windows update Web site).

I could be wrong in this, but it seems like a Crap-Shoot to me. The only way to know 
is Roll-the Dice, but be prepared for problems with a Full system Backup on a separate 
HDD or Removable Media. 

I would not rely on the Uninstall SP3 feature, since it's doubtful that it will return 
a fully functional system. Same goes for System Restore, which is Historically un-reliable.

Just my opinion, but untill MS is confident enough to release SP3 on CD, I'm going 
to leave it alone. I might make exception if my System should fail and require a 
Clean install, to get it up-and running.

Reiterating, If you have kept your System up-todate, SP3 has nothing new for you. 
It won't/can't help, but certainly can hurt.

Again IMHO, based on recent increase in SP3 problems posted on various WinXP Forums.

BW




There's nothing to learn from someone who already agrees with you.

_________________________________________________________




On Monday, May 12, 2008 at 2:35 am, RM Weston wrote:

>Anyone who's willing to give feedback on their experience with SP3? I've seen some 

>complaints elsewhere online that I wouldn't want to experience, so I came here to 

>get recommendations from sane people! Thanks for this great site. 

• Reply or follow-up to this message

• Search this forum
• Start a new thread on a different subject

• Report abuse of the forum